Power Line: Howlers

January 11, 2005

Howlers

Today's best commentary on the Rathergate Report is Jonathan Last's at the Standard Online: "Whitewash." Last identifies the agnosticism of the report on the documents' authenticity, the failure of the report to investigate the origin of the documents, and the utter credulity of the report on the 60 Minutes story's motivation as key elements of the report that cannot withstand scrutiny.

The blatant fraudulence of the Burkett documents should have been the conclusion that was the predicate for a serious investigation of the key issues raised by the 60 Minutes story. The report's failure to draw a conclustion regarding the authenticity of the documents disqualifies it from consideration as a serious document. It is in my view a failure that discredits the report as an exercise in damage control for CBS.

In critical respects the report severs its narrative of the 60 Minutes story from the context of the presidential campaign that was its impetus. It fails to follow up on or draw inferences from the producers' email correspondence (noted by Rocket Man here) hypothetically marketing the story's "information that could change the momentum of an election[.]"

The report leaves the question of political motivation and bias with the ipse dixit of Dan Rather (who, me?) and Mary Mapes ("proximity, not politics"...how about relocating her to Massachusetts?). Is this some kind of a joke? Did Thornburgh or Boccari think to ask whether Rather and Mapes opposed the reelection of President Bush, or any other follow-up question that might have shed some light on the issue? Apparently not, at least so far as is apparent on the face of the report.

Anyone who reads the report with care, cognizant of the context of the 60 Minutes story in the presidential campaign, will find the elements of the report identified by Last to be howlers.

Posted by Scott at 06:52 AM |

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.powerlineblog.com/mt/mt-diespammers.cgi/9223

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Howlers:

» Four CBS Employees Fired Over Rathergate and "Myopic Zeal" from La Shawn Barber's Corner
Heads rolled! These are what the consequences of sloppy journalism should be. In a failed attempt to smear George Bush, four employees at CBS were FIRED over their role in Rathergate:The action was prompted by the report of an independent panel that co... [Read More]

Tracked on January 11, 2005 08:13 AM

» CBS says "guilty but not biased" from Jeff Blogworthy.com
Alan Colmes, of Hannity and Colmes fame, certainly found his favorite line from the CBS report on the Bush National Guard story, released today:The question of whether a political agenda played any role in the airing of the Segment is one of the most subj [Read More]

Tracked on January 11, 2005 09:01 AM

» More on Dan Rather from Reagan Republican
I think that part of the reason Dan Rather resigned from CBS (or was forced to quit) was to avoid a more in-depth and lengthy investigation into what happened. He got axed, we won, the libs lost, end of story. Imagine if Clinton had had the integrity... [Read More]

Tracked on January 11, 2005 09:23 AM

» http://posseincitatus.typepad.com/posse_incitatus/2005/01/powerline_has_a.html from Posse Incitatus
Powerline has a series of posts reacting to the CBS report on Memogate. [Read More]

Tracked on January 11, 2005 09:36 AM

» Martyrs of the Memogate report from Posse Incitatus
Powerline has a series of posts reacting to the CBS report on Memogate. [Read More]

Tracked on January 11, 2005 09:37 AM

» Rathergate Wrap-Up and the Howlers from FullosseousFlap's Dental Blog
The Big Trunk at Powerline has this great piece on the CBS flap with Dan Rather: Howlers Today's best commentary on the Rathergate Report is Jonathan Last's at the Standard Online: "Whitewash." Last identifies the agnosticism of the report on t... [Read More]

Tracked on January 11, 2005 09:42 AM

» Define Bias from Not So Much
The left has jumped on the finding that there is was no political bias like Rosie O'Donnell on a young orphan carrying a bag of malomars. [Read More]

Tracked on January 11, 2005 10:57 AM

» Rathergate Report Roundup from Myopic Zeal
The blogosphere is buzzing. Michelle Malkin: Reuters Gets it Wrong Lashawn comments: PDF of Rathergate Report WizBang's paginated web version Powerline here and here. PoliPundit here and here. Whitewash Benedict Lots more fr... [Read More]

Tracked on January 11, 2005 12:46 PM

» Self-evident to all but the experts from Petrified Truth
So the Thornburgh-Boccardi panel has found fault with the journalistic practices at CBS News, but declined to find "evidence" of "political bias" or document forgery. That's more than bizarre, since the truth is obvious: the incident itself and all the... [Read More]

Tracked on January 11, 2005 01:26 PM

» Some Heads Roll... from Ipse Dixit
Ipse Dixit would like to state for the record that we had whatsoever nothing to do with either Dan Rather's or Mary Mapes' self-serving denials, nor were we involved in any way with any ... [Read More]

Tracked on January 11, 2005 03:01 PM

» Two Americas? by Richard from Epoch3Blog
After digesting the contents of the CBS report and reading both the disclaimers and denials of some of the principal players, as well as some reasoned discussion from fellow bloggers, in particular [Read More]

Tracked on January 11, 2005 06:31 PM

Tracked on January 11, 2005 06:34 PM

Tracked on January 11, 2005 06:37 PM

Tracked on January 11, 2005 06:41 PM

» Good Think-Piece on Rathergate from Ace of Spades HQ
Cedarford tips to this piece by the amateur (but paid) leftist webzine Slate. If Slate keeps this up, they'll be nearly as good as, say, the amateur unpaid citizen-journalists like Power Line: CBS's remedy fit the usual blue-ribbon-panel-submits-its-de... [Read More]

Tracked on January 11, 2005 07:43 PM